Showing posts with label Independent Media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Independent Media. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

I Saw The News Today, Oh Boy

Well, yesterday. I haven't looked at the news today, so I'm not at all caught up with overnight events, but what I saw yesterday helped illuminate just how far from reality much of our news media typically is.

I was, for example, watching the CBS Evening News and the NewsHour, that PBS stalwart, and CBS and Gwen and Company were quite taken up with events in Ferguson and elsewhere as well they should be, but a good deal of the "news" was wrong, false, lies, and what have you. That's a problem. That has been a problem for many a long year, but came into stark focus during the reports of "rioting" in Ferguson in response to the Grand Jury failure to indict the Warrior Sheepdog and Demon Destroyer Darren Wilson.

First of all, the "rioting" was a construct of Authority and the media working in concert, as my ground-eye  view via Bassem Masri's and Rebelutionary_Z's livestreams amply demonstrated. There was no rioting, not by the demonstrators. And the police, typically, were lying about what was going on.

I also watched Amy Goodman's report from the ground in Ferguson, and she basically confirmed with her own eyes what I was seeing on the livestreams and twitter pictures. There were no police and no National Guard on the streets of Ferguson beyond the police headquarters area on South Florissant which is basically in the White Area of Florissant. The 20-some-odd businesses that burned were on West Florissant, in the Negro District. All of the police (and apparently later, the National Guard, though that's not certain) in Ferguson were deployed to protect "The Fort" as I call it; none were assigned to guard or protect businesses along West Florissant. So businesses burned, and it's sad.

The crowd of protesters was assembled at "The Fort" and they were gassed  and largely driven away by a pincer-action of heavily armed and militarized police. Two police cars were burned. How that happened is still a mystery, but both cars were behind police lines when they caught fire. Those were, so far as I could tell, the only incidents of "violence" in that area of Ferguson, apart, of course, from the extensive use of teargas and flash-bangs by the police.

The crowd initially was several thousand strong protesting in front of "The Fort," but it dwindled to a few hundred, perhaps only a few dozen, after repeated the application of teargas.  The crowd was not violent, they were not rioting. A few individuals were vandalizing one of the police cars, a car someone said was left in the street for just that purpose. Could be. But others pointed out that the vandals were unknown, and at least some were white.

By the time Bassem's phone was stolen -- he said by a "police agitator" -- the crowd was small and relatively dispersed in the area of "The Fort." There were very few people on the streets elsewhere in Ferguson. I saw a few pictures taken at the memorial to Mike Brown on Canfield Drive, for example, and it looked very quiet. Amy Goodman stopped by there too, and there was no sign of riot or crowds.

The fires on West Florissant need to be investigated and explained. I'm sure there is some security camera and other video that would show how they started and who was responsible. It's really quite amazing that so much police presence could be deployed to suppress nonviolent protest at the police station but none at all was available to protect people and property along West Florissant, where vandalism and arson had occurred in August.

That was one thing. According to the narrative pushed by Authority and the media, however, rampaging rioters were battling with police all over. And it simply wasn't true. Police were attacking nonviolent protesters at the police headquarters in Ferguson and they were letting businesses be looted and burned along West Florissant without any police or the fire department. When this fact was noted, it was "copsplained" by saying "it wasn't safe" for police or fire responders to go to West Florissant. Rampaging Negroes and all... Bullshit bullshit bullshit.

Meanwhile, a huge contingent of police, I discovered through Rebelutionary_Z's archived videos from the previous night, had been deployed at the intersection of Grand and Shaw Arsenal in the South County. They fired teargas at the relatively small crowd that gathered there, and apparently they twice fired teargas at the MoKabe coffee house, a designated "Safe Space" Police were out in force in this area of Shaw/Tower Grove, unlike the case along West Florissant in Ferguson,  and were issuing contradictory and absurd commands, arresting people pretty much at random, and having a fine old time with their crowd suppression toys.

Rebelutionary_Z had traveled to this area from the safe house where he'd rested after the freeway shut down. Reports were coming in that that safe house (a church) had been raided by police and tear gas had been used. In the area of MoKabe's, along Grand Avenue, Z documented several broken windows and one pawn shop merchant clearing the broken glass from his place was pissed. He confronted Z for "profiting off his pain" -- I thought that was odd, because it's hard to say that Z is "profiting," but Z did not respond. And he didn't mention the incident again.

Meanwhile, the police were behaving in an arbitrary manner, sometimes appearing in force and riot gear to confront the chanting crowd, other times withdrawing, only to return, firing flash-bangs and tear gas and ordering dispersal -- which for some was not possible because they were trapped.

"Negotiations" were conducted to allow people to leave MoKabe's, but the "negotiations" seemed odd, forced, and largely false. People were told they could leave -- with their hands up -- and head toward the church that had been raided and gassed. That didn't seem like much of a resolution to the dilemma of how to disperse when they were not allowed to, and by this point, few people had any trust in the word of the police, word which had already been repeatedly broken.

Nevertheless, people did leave with their hands up and headed toward the other safe place -- that wasn't safe at all.

There was a "clergy" woman (I don't know who she was, I'd never seen her before) mediating between the crowd and police and she often stood and walked between them, almost always with her hands up as a kind of sacrificial lamb, and I'm convinced that her presence defused some of the potential for police violence.  But she couldn't do anything but shrug about the arbitrary nature of police commands. It's their culture, you know?

I spent all morning yesterday watching that and other archived videos of the previous night's events, and I was quite moved by the dedication and determination of the protesters and their almost completely non-violent militance.

It's clear that these demonstrations, which have now spread all over the country and seem to be focusing actions on shutting down freeways (a time honored way to discommode the apathetic and comfortable), are well-coordinated and planned as opposed to some of the Occupy actions which they sometimes resemble.

The issues being raised in these actions -- police abuse and killing with complete impunity -- are much closer to the reality the victims face in this country than the somewhat abstract though no less destructive issues Occupy grappled and grapples with. The chord that has been touched in so many places with regard to police abuse and murder is one that can't be untouched, as practically everywhere, and every day, people -- often children or completely innocent people -- are being shot down by police, many of whom are terrified of their own shadows.

This has got to stop. The only way for people without power to force this or any other issue is to discommode those with power, and make their voices heard, whatever it takes. That means persistent protest (the Mike Brown protests have been going on daily for three months, after all) and creative discommoding. Shutting down bridges and freeways is a good tactic, but causing financial pain to those in power can be even better.

It's a long haul process. Occupy burrowed in to communities and is now a leading volunteer service outlet in communities all over the country. It's as radical as ever, but not so much a public spectacle. Participants do good works and help enable oppressed communities to take control of their own fate.

In the case of these police accountability demonstrations, it's more difficult to achieve objectives because the police don't work for the people, and there is often no easy way for the people to force change on the institution -- or to withdraw from interaction with it.

The police serve their masters, and that means they behave like an army of occupation because that's what their masters want. The occupation can be lifted, but only when their masters say so. Sometimes the occupation can be subverted or crippled, but that's a long-haul and highly risky endeavor. The actions taking place have a cumulative effect, especially the ongoing national demonstrations, but the result may not be quite what anybody hopes for.


Nevertheless, Onward! and Solidarity!

Saturday, March 15, 2014

Amy Goodman at the Lensic, March 14, 2014




Amy Goodman is really an amazing raconteur. I give her mad props for that.

Of course, she's been on this tour for a while now, and she's been to Santa Fe once or twice a year for who knows how long (she indicated quite a few times...) so none of this is new to her. Nevertheless, she was able to weave together so many disparate-seeming threads in her... talk (it wasn't a speech or a lecture) that ran a little over an hour, that the effect was extraordinary. From the KKK repeatedly blowing up the Pacifica Radio transmitter tower in Houston, to the Fukushima story which ran recently on DN! -- and which I thought was superb -- to the Troy Davis vigil in Georgia,  to visiting the graves of Frederick Douglass and Susan B. Anthony in Rochester the midst of a snow storm (did that ever bring back memories for me!) and missing her plane to Denver because of it, to the nuclear issue in New Mexico, to Donald Rumsfeld's Eastern Shore estate in Maryland which was the plantation called "Mt Misery" where the rebellious Frederick Douglass had been taken to be broken, tortured into compliance as a slave, ironically next door to the Cheney estate, to the 2011 uprisings in Tahrir, in Madison, and in Manhattan and to all the other uprisings that grew from them (as Frida Barrington says, "little insurrections"), to the RNC convention in St. Paul (she didn't mention her detention, I wonder why), and on and on; I'm sure more will come to me.

The theme, not surprisingly, was alternative, public and independent media -- and how essential they are to anything like a functioning democracy. While she touted her own experiences, the message was that all the media players outside the contracting shrinking corporate media sector are essential and are essentially working together on this project called "truth" -- truth to power, truth about power, truth without power beyond the true voices of the people themselves.

So I asked her afterwards what she thought the future of alternative, public and independent media would be now that all these billionaires were entering the field, buying up not only programs (as on PBS and CPB) and the news itself (as on NewsHour) but so many of the very voices of the field (ie: First Look/Pierre).

She shot me a look as if I had just farted in her face, as if to say, "Couldn't you please ask me about something else?"  and I didn't think she was going to answer at all. Then she sort of looked up and said, "Mmmm, I dunno.... we'll have to see. As long as the work is good, that's the important thing. I don't have much else to say about it... for now."  I rather curtly responded, "How... diplomatic of you," and she shot me that look again.

Clearly it is a topic that makes her uncomfortable. The stories about the corruption of PBS and CPB by billionaires who fund programs that promote their political agendas have gotten a surprising amount of traction, given where they originated (ie: Pando, a Billionaire Boy's Club arm's length investment -- ahem)  and  the whole First Look Thing has got a lot of people scratching their heads over what it might lead to -- and no, Glenn, the questioning isn't over what "Pierre" tells you to write, it's about what you and all the rest don't write about -- so as not to displease your check-writer, boss, and host. M-kay?

I've never known who funds "Democracy Now! Democracy Now! dot org. The War and Peace Report" though I understand it's quite an expensive enterprise and they get big-bucks foundation grants (so I would ask, what stories don't they tell because of who funds them?) But I am somewhat familiar with what happened at Pacifica when pleasing corporate/foundation interest became more important than anything else among the Pacifica board and management -- under the guise of "professionalizing," triggering a revolt (not the whole story, but some of it, from a particular point of view) and a good deal of public blood letting took place over what was going on. It was ugly. No, it was really ugly. Amy reported on it, as I recall, or tried to, and was taken off the air. I haven't read the link to refresh my memory, but if I recall correctly, and it's been a while, her plug was pulled in the midst of a broadcast. For sometime thereafter, Pacifica ran archived shows. During the time this was going on, KPFA was on my car radio, and was practically unlistenable.

All media is going through a somewhat painful phase, which she alluded to in her talk. As the General Manager of New Mexico PBS, Franz Joaquim, said in his intro, "It's the best of times. It's the worst of times." (or maybe it was Dave Marash, KSFR's news director who said it, the intros are something of a fog at this point). I get that. At the same time, if media -- all media with a substantial audience -- is going to fall under the wing of some foundation or billionaire benefactor or corporate boardroom or it isn't going to exist, then the media as an institution has failed. Badly. The myth of the Free Press is then what it's long been held to be: "The press is free enough -- so long as you can afford to buy one."

During the uprisings of 2011, we got a taste of what a modern real independent people powered media can look like. Livestreamers were everywhere, many Occupys had print publications, too, and online news directly from the scenes and sources exploded (not solely via Twitter and Facebook, but mainly so). Getting a rope around all that became an obvious state objective, but there was also an internal effort through the various Occupys to control the news. Livestreamers found themselves in a bind when what they were showing was not what certain factions wanted seen. Some were attacked, several quit.  It sometimes was or became a donnybrook. But it was much closer to what real "independent media" looks like than even Democracy Now! or First Look or anything else that claims the title of "independent" or "alternative" media. In that context, PBS and NPR don't even factor. They are the equivalent of "corporate-state" media.

What the future of American media holds is still very much up in the air. Amy said that the People have to take back their media, and while it's an appealing phrase, God knows, the truth of the matter is that the People never had a media to "take back." There were signs in 2011 and 2012 (as there have been before) that an actual "People's Media" might develop. Certainly the tools are available at practically no financial cost. The basic infrastructure for genuine "People's Media" is in place. But making it so is still fraughtful, and efforts so far have been halting or halted due to conflicting interests and demands.

The traditional media seems to be in only slightly better shape.

Stay tuned.

Monday, February 10, 2014

First Look Launches "The Intercept"

Kinda low-key launch, it seems to me, for the Big Reveal of the Greenwald/Poitras/Scahill venture under "Pierre's" wing at First Look Media.

There are two stories and a "welcome" post in this initial effort.

One story consists of nightime pictures of some of the NatSec facilities in the DC area, apparently taken from a rented helicopter by Trevor Paglen. They're kind of pretty, though they primarily show parking lots. Well, yes. That would be right. Even the daytime pictures of NatSec facilities primarily show parking lots. And (believe it or not) you have to have a permit/pass to get into them. The parking lots themselves, which tend to surround the facilities, serve as barriers to access (by those who are unauthorized, dontchaknow). But Paglen doesn't get in to any of that, he just wants to show the pretty pictures, and the pictures are nice, make no mistake. It's good to be able to visualize these places. One place he doesn't show, however, is the CIA headquarters in Langley, VA. Apparently, CIA refused him permission to photograph the facility from his rented helicopter. Luckily, there is no lack of imagery available on the Google.

The other story is about the NSA's provision of targeting information to JSOC and drone operators in various "war" theaters used for liquidating terrorist suspects. Though bylined Greenwald and Scahill, it's obviously mostly Scahill's writing. A bit of it may be Greenwald's, but I doubt very much of it is.

The story is interesting on its merits, but it's got some problems, a major one in my view being its failure to question JSOC's mission -- and the policies of assassination and murder, only the tactics and the reliance on sometimes erroneous intelligence from the NSA. In addition to failing to question JSOC's mission, the story uses terminology which declares targets "terrorists" without questioning that designation. There are some uses of scare quotes from time to time in this very long and detailed article (something like Jeremy might have written for the Nation when time was and which is certainly reminiscent of "Dirty Wars"), which may present the appearance of questioning the standard, official terminology, but in fact, there is never a question about the terminology, only the expression of regret that "mistakes are sometimes made." OK, then.

Finally, I was initially struck by the near absence of any mention of the CIA in this story. They are referred to, but only in passing, early on in the story, as if the CIA is a branch of the military, when in fact, of course, the NSA is the branch of the military which is charged with supplying military intelligence. 

It's long been my understanding that many of the targeted killing/Death From Above program(s) involve the CIA, and more than a few are run independently by the Company itself, but what I got from the initial paragraphs othat CIA involvement in these things is peripheral, and that's just not right.

I have little doubt Jeremy is aware of that fact. But in "Dirty Wars," he claimed that even after being in Iraq for three years, he'd never heard of JSOC, and didn't learn of it until he got to Afghanistan, even though JSOC was carrying out a vicious campaign of terror and murder in Iraq right in front of his disbelieving eyes while he was there. It seemed to me that he was being deliberately disingenuous or deceptive about what he knew and didn't know, as there was no lack of reportage regarding the Death Squads in Iraq (I think some of that reporting came from Jeremy himself) nor was there any lack of reporting naming JSOC as the Valiant American Lead in establishing and carrying out the campaigns of terror and murder that wracked Iraq for years during the American Occupation.

As I got further into the article, however, suddenly the CIA appears (deus ex machina-like) out of nowhere taking over the hunt for al-Awlaki in the Yemen when JSOC fails to find and liquidate him. OK. Prior to that, it seems that the CIA is merely along for the ride provided by the NSA and JSOC. Interestingly, one of the sources for the story, Brandon Bryant, a former drone operator, criticizes the CIA for its "indiscriminate" targeting for liquidation, and he frets that CIA practices are afflicting the NSA and JSOC operations. Good doG in heaven...

There are also a number of stand-alone graphics in the piece which are for the most part not identified as to source or provenance. They appear to be selected quotes from Snowden-trove documents, but who knows...

In the "welcome" article -- rather obviously written by Greenwald, though bylined Greenwald, Poitras and Scahill -- we are treated to a recapitulation of most of the tropes about "accountability and transparency" we've been hearing from Greenwald for years. The initial focus on the NSA is excused as the "short-term" focus; eventually, "The Intercept" will be getting into other matters. Patience, grasshopper.

The article strongly suggests that "The Intercept" is an independent project of Greenwald, Poitras (the Invisible One) and Scahill that is merely being published by First Look Media. The implication is that "The Intercept" pre-dates First Look/Omidyar involvement, and if so, that's interesting, since apparently First Look Media's incorporation pre-dates Snowden's Booz Allen sojourn. (Which led me to speculate that -- perhaps -- Snowden and Omidyar had some connection in Hawaii -- where Omidyar lives and Snowden used to live before the Big HooHah -- prior to Snowden's contact with Poitras and Greenwald. Oh, what tangled webs, wheels within wheels, etc...)

Interesting too is Greenwald's nearly obsessive focus on the "threats" made against him and "journalism" by so many officials.

 Over the past seven months the journalists who have reported on these documents from the National Security Agency have been repeatedly threatened by a wide range of government officials. Sometimes, the intimidation campaign has gone beyond mere threats. These attempted intimidation tactics have intensified in recent weeks and have become clearly more concerted and coordinated.

This is one of his tropes, and it has always struck me as... well, crap. Though "Show Business" is probably more like it. These constantly hyped "threats" have never had any substance behind them. So Mike Rogers is running his mouth. Big. Fucking. Deal. Unlike HUAC and other governmental operations -- both current and historical -- Rogers and Feinstein and so on have no direct power to harm him or "journalism" as a trade and craft. They run their mouths -- it's part of their job.

Just as Greenwald sees it as his crusade to be the modern embodiment of Old Testament Prophets and thunder against them. It's Show Business.

Greenwald also asserts that the principals of "The Intercept" will engage with readers in the comment section, but among the more than 150 comments to the "welcome" post, Greenwald is the only one who does so, and it is only to acknowledge two "long-time" commenters and readers who have arrived to hail the new venture.

Many of the other commenters are clearly writing English as a second language, which is also interesting.

All in all, "The Intercept" strikes me as a surprisingly modest undertaking which may turn into something substantial over time -- or may fizzle out once the thrill of the NSA revelations is gone.

We shall see.
--------------------------------------------
UPDATE: 02/12/14
Froomkin now has a post up at "The Intercept" basically rehashing Jeremy's post and pretty much everything else that's been reported about the Snowden Trove to date. In it, Froomkin, like Scahill, does not question the policies only the tactics involved. Clearly the failure to question the policies of the drone wars and so much else in these initial posts at the "Intercept" is a conscious editorial decision, not a temporary lapse -- as some have tried to claim. On the other hand, given that everything "The Intercept" has so far published is "old news" (or in the case of the nighttime pictures of NatSec facilities, somewhat of a distraction) and there are no documents yet posted at all -- though unlabeled excerpts (from somewhere) are included in Jeremy's post -- it's little wonder some people suspect "The Intercept" is a bad joke. I wouldn't go that far, simply because the startup is as slow as it is, and there is much still to sort out (including clashing egos, I have no doubt.) There's still the question, too, of what kind of influence, if any, "Pierre" has on the venture. To say he has none would be, I think, criminally naive. But how much he may have is an open question. Meanwhile, I had my doubts this thing would launch at all, in part due to those inevitable ego-clashes. So I was wrong about that. Nevertheless, the launch is so low-key as to be practically mute. The "news" is old, the documents are not there, and the feel overall is pretty amateur and clunky.

Given all that, it may be strange to see me say, "It would be nice if it worked." But that's how I feel. I'd rather it didn't fail, but unless something happens to goose it up, I suspect it's not going to amount to very much. A digital hang-out, perhaps, and a blog-home for some writers...
 ------------------------------------------
UPDATE: 02/11/14
Now having looked over the story again -- it is awfully long and in places quite dense -- and after having seen Jeremy's performance on Democracy Now! yesterday, I may be seeing a rationale for Jeremy's reluctance to question (in the "Intercept" story) the policies or the terminologies involved. In fact, as he has many times before, in his Democracy Now! appearance, he did question the policies -- and terminology -- and did so quite forcefully, as has previously been his way. It was rather striking to me that he didn't do so in his inaugural effort for "The Intercept,"  though. Why didn't he? Perhaps because of the function of the site? Is it to attack policies? Or is it to attack players on behalf of opposing factions?

Quite a few people are convinced that the Snowden Leak is a two fold matter: 1) a limited hangout to demonstrate to the public that they are "being watched" by some nefarious agency/agents of government, and they better not get out of line or "the man come and take them away"; 2) a hit by the CIA on the NSA for fucking up and fucking them over.  There is nothing at all in Jeremy's story to refute either notion; in fact, it reinforces both. The message is that your cell phone is a tracking and locating device which the surveillance services can use to locate you and -- if  so ordered -- liquidate you by any means necessary, and that the security services (ie: police, CIA, military, death squads, who knows who else?) will cheerfully carry out your liquidation, even if they are wrong.

Have a nice day.




------------------------------------------

Also too: the comment count on Jeremy's drone story went from 37 or something this morning to well over 200 in the space of a couple of hours, after Greenwald's commentariat (and their numerous sock-puppets) arrived en masse. In fact, it was pretty easy to spot the bot-comments and the socks because they all said approximately the same thing (essentially nothing except "Congrats!"). Adding: Later, they got into brawls and arguments with one another, as they tended to do at the Guardian and Salon.

Over at the Guardian they could get the comment count up into the thousands in a day's time.

We'll see whether they are able to do that here.

-------------------------------------------

Further on the comments: the numbers are quickly rising, but the caliber of  commentary has declined precipitously, mostly into the weeds of conspiracy, insults, and complete bullshit. Inevitable, I suppose...

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Sleep Deprivation and Independent Media and The Dawning

Tim Pool, video streamer for OWS during the recent eviction and its aftermath


During the ongoing saga that is the Occupy Wall Street Movement (becoming a Revolution -- aka: "Occupy") the video streams have been the main way to gain on-the-spot visual news of what's really going on in the Movement.

I became an early devotee to OWS's Livestreams through Global Revolution out of New York. They were the main means I had of touching base, as it were, with the General Assemblies and the formation of Working Groups and the sights and sounds -- if not exactly the smells -- of the scene on the Plaza and the marches.

And, as soon as other Occupies got going, I tuned in to whatever video streaming they were able to manage, which put me front and center with some of the more astonishing developments -- and struggles -- within the movement. I won't detail all of them here, because that's not the point of this post, but I'll just say that without the video streaming from the Occupations themselves, I would know next to nothing about any of them. As it is, I've become familiar with quite a few and have come to recognize participants all over the country, which is part of what has clued me to the fact that this is a very profound and ultimately can be a very productive Movement that really IS 'Teh Revolution' I have been blathering about one day coming. It's here. It's real. It's now.

But I pretty much abandoned NYC's video stream weeks and weeks ago -- ages in Revolution time -- because it was completely unreliable; when it was on at all, it was usually extremely choppy, and often it was simply useless. This struck me as strange, since Livestreaming and other video streams were crucial for the public's understanding of what it was like during the North African and some of the European uprisings, and -- except when the Governments interfered -- they seemed to work fine with little or no choppiness, pixelation, or irrelevance. But New York's Livestream channels were almost always fraught with extraordinary bad luck. Sometimes they would only work for seconds at a time and then be down for hours. And then when a stream was up again, it would run re-runs or other feeds or whatever was available but nothing live. I saw from some of their records that they spent tens of thousands of dollars on new equipment and they were constantly getting donations of more. But the streams still sucked.

I really did come to believe that there was serious sabotage going on, because none of the other streams I was checking had nearly as many severe problems as NYC's did. Every other city I checked that had a video stream had relatively minor problems that seemed related more to the fact that amateurs were trying to figure out how best to work it, but they did work. Not OWS in New York. There were sometimes alternate NYC channels that seemed to work fine, but they were temporary at best, often just fleeting hit and run or one-off type documentation. But OWS's own streams never worked well for very long.

So it was kind of amazing when I found a link to Wearetheother99.com's videostream from New York on Monday morning after the Raid. According to what I've been able to find out on their website, they've been streaming all along -- since day one? -- but I never knew about it. There was no indication in any of the information I was accumulating that there even was this particular video stream. It was certainly not mentioned in any of the OWS streaming that I was aware of. That doesn't mean there was actually no mention of it; it means that I didn't see it, and given the nature of the operation, it's easy to miss something. There are many places where information is stored and retrieved from; you just have to keep looking -- or in my case, stop looking, and concentrate on those places where I could find information: the OWS Website and the NYCGA Website, along with Occupy Together. Of course, they weren't necessarily reliable either! NYCGA's is particularly dicey because it has gone through repeated redesigns that require constant renavigation and have resulted in the loss of plenty of documentation that once was there.

So, back to my topic; got off track there for a little bit. The image above is a screen grab of Tim Pool from last night. He was just about to sign off after more than 19 hours' video streaming what was going on in New York. As I say, I only found the link to this stream on Monday morning, and that only by chance. The OWS Livestreams were as sucky as ever when they were working at all. Somebody posted a link to Wearetheother99's videostream in some chat, I don't think it was even OWS's, I think I was checking Berkeley at the time, and I clicked the link. Sure enough; Tim Pool was on his way to Zuccotti, having marched to Trinity Church and then when he learned that there was a TRO that allowed demonstrators back in the Plaza, he headed back to Zuccotti (as he called it, he rarely referred to it as Liberty anything) with a large contingent of those who had gone to Trinity as an alternate site. (Visualize Lower Manhattan and you'll get an idea of how these locations relate to each other. Or Google it up... I've been down there a few times in my life, and even though I haven't been there in many years, the layout is still pretty easy to picture in my mind's eye.)

On the march back to Zuccotti, he was explaining what had happened, and this was the first clear reporting of the events of the night before I had heard; there were sketchy "news" reports that the OWS Occupation had been raided, and I'd seen Amy Goodman's "aftermath" report -- which was horrifying -- but I'd heard and seen nothing much from those who had actually been there, nor was it clear at the time what people were going to do about it.

Tim had been there from just after 1am, and he had stayed with the OWS participants, video-streaming the whole time, from that point. On the march back to the Plaza, he inadvertently gave out his phone number, and since he was using his smart phone as the video-stream camera, the stream got cut off repeatedly every time a call came in. He stopped at a Sprint store on the way back to the Plaza and got his number changed so that he could keep streaming. Then his batteries were dying despite the fact that he had been given a heavy backpack full of equipment by Justin (Wedes -- his interview with Amy Goodman is posted below) and was using Justin's MacBook as a trickle charger for his phone camera. He asked if anyone could get him another battery as he didn't think he would have enough charge to get back to the Plaza. In fact, people did get him batteries, and he did get back to the Plaza and a few minutes downtime while he changed batteries, he was continuously streaming until well after 10:00pm EST Tuesday night.

Because his was the only reliable video stream on the scene, it was picked up by Time.com, Huffington Post, Al Jazeera, and apparently was being mirrored all over the Livestream network. He had over 11,000 viewers on his own channel, but with all these others tagging along, he figured there might have been 100,000 viewers overall. There may have been many more than that.

And he was -- of course -- completely sleep-deprived, hungry, thirsty and exhausted. He was also lugging Justin's heavy bag around with him. He became so tired, he could barely walk, but he kept streaming, kept interviewing people, kept looking for news he could share. This heavy bag of Justin's was an incredible burden however, and it became something of a metaphor for all the "stuff" that had been accumulating at Zuccotti during the Occupation, nearly all of which was swept away by the Raid. Most of it apparently swept away and hauled off to the dump -- after promises were made that personal property could be retrieved at such and such a location after such and such a time.

That was the scene that Amy Goodman had shown -- huge mounds of debris being loaded into garbage trucks for disposal, most of consisting of the personal property of the Occupiers who had been dispossessed and evicted.

Tim lost his tent and everything in it in the Raid, but he had his own video-stream equipment, his innate communications skill and he was Carrying On -- and also carrying Justin's heavy bag. The search for Justin became an integral part of the saga Tim was transmitting. The rumor was that Justin had been arrested, but no one knew for sure. The Bag, though, was becoming an intolerable burden; Tim could not go on any longer carrying it -- he'd been carrying it for 17 hours and it was HEAVY. Finally, he encountered one of Justin's friends; she didn't know where he was. She tried calling him on her phone, but there was no response. I believe they texted him as well, with no luck. She said she would take The Bag, though, and make sure Justin got it since she knew where he lived (in Brooklyn or The Bronx, I don't recall off hand).

Tim was so relieved. EVERYONE watching was so relieved. It was Liberation. And it was a similar sense of Liberation to that of the renewed Occupation of Zuccotti, without all the appurtenances that had built up over the past two months. Many of those who lost some personal property in the Raid seemed to realize they were Liberated from Things now and could concentrate more on Doing.

What the Occupy Movement is in many ways is a Demonstration of how to be and do another world -- as Gandhi said, "Be the change you seek in the world." The Demonstration at Zuccotti was one thing, but much of it could be done anywhere. It didn't have to be solely in the Plaza. In fact, most of that Demonstration -- of another way of being and doing -- didn't have to be in that Plaza at all, it could be anywhere in the city or ultimately anywhere in the world.

Having and holding a space, a place, was important, and despite his exhaustion and sleep deprivation, Tim was documenting the excitement and determination of getting the Space back. But he was also noting and showing the realization among many that the Space and the Demonstration were not necessities for one another.

This is a powerful realization, one that was already being made in Oakland, though not quite as clearly and concretely, after their Raid and dispossession. In Oakland, the Raid that destroyed their camp the second time was greeted with an almost festive -- certainly not a fearful -- air. And that Raid, too, was documented by an outstanding -- and massively sleep deprived -- videostreamer named Spencer, who goes by OakFoSho on Ustream. He then headed off to Berkeley to document their Occupation, which I was watching early this morning.

In Berkeley, too, there seemed to be a growing recognition that having and holding Space was important -- and they were allowed to stay on Sproul Plaza by the very polite police, at least for the night -- but that the Demonstration that Another World Is Possible could happen anywhere.

The Space is Important, but the Demonstration is even more important.

I have nothing but praise for Tim and Spencer and the video-streamers who have been working so hard everywhere to get the real news out rather than the ridiculous "narrative" of the MSM. The contrast couldn't be more startling. And they are all doing it as dedicated amateurs with often very limited or primitive equipment, under difficult and dangerous circumstances with few if any pecuniary rewards.

This is Independent Media. And this is the Future.

The Revolutionary Future. Strap in. The ride is gonna get bumpier...