Monday, June 18, 2012

So Why Do People Vote Against Their Own Best Interests?



I would argue that from their perspective they've done no such thing.

Their perspective may be wrong to be sure. But they don't know that at the time. Most often, they can't know it.

It's a matter of social and cultural conditioning, of propaganda, of deep seated fears, of threats and imprecations, of promised rewards and of an inner need to do what is right for oneself and one's posterity. All normal stimuli and responses under the circumstances.

And yet responding normally is somehow wrong? Since the result of the action can't be known in advance, it's hard to see where it is wrong for a People to vote in the way they think is appropriate under their circumstances at the time -- and hope for the best.

As we see in Greece, the issues are not clear cut in the eyes of the People; they continue to evince tepid support for a standard model rightist solution to their existential crisis, but they are trending more and more to the Left, with strong showings by the Left coalition and the even-further Left, ie: the Communists.

The odd-man-out is the Socialist Party (ΠΑΣΟΚ) which can't seem to win for losing. But then, selling out tends to have that effect.

Meanwhile in France the Socialists gained a clear majority in the National Assembly and so Hollande has a mandate going forward. Into what is the question. France and Germany appear to be on a collision course with regard to the proper treatment of the Periphery. But then, are they? Really? Frau Merkel seems quite capable of steamrolling and stonewalling to get her way until the very last minute -- or as they say the last dog dies. She seems to be modeling herself after Baroness Thatcher in her dealings with the fringes of Europe, and she's getting away with it. On the other hand, Hollande is a blank slate; the Socialist platform may be one thing and his perspective something else. Since Socialists and Social Democrats all over Europe have been more than willing to sell their People out for the promise of reward under the New World Order or what have you, I wouldn't put much faith in the Elysee Palace's ability to sway Berlin from its current path of domination, exploitation and ruin for all who don't pay appropriate tribute.

The economic policies out of Berlin and Brussels are insane on their merits, but they're typical of the predominate neo-liberal economics out of all the highest institutions in the world these days. Banksters rule with an iron fist, and they will fuck up whole nations that don't go along with them pronto and fully.

Frau Merkel, Mme Legarde and Signore Draghi all pull the wagon for the Banksters. Legarde and Draghi ARE Banksters; Merkel's service unto them and unto the Berlin Banksters in defiance of common sense and decency (let alone basic macro economics) is -- or would be -- inexplicable, but for the fact that she says the German Volk are behind her (as her party loses election after election in the German States.)

And we may at some point to ask how exactly it came to be that the Banksters were allowed to overwhelm common sense and a decent regard for mankind in their pursuit of obscene profits based on... nothing. What happened to enable this triumph of greed, parsimony and stupidity?

And what, exactly, are the People to do under the circumstances?

In Europe, it appears that the People have recognized that they are essentially unable to affect the policy decisions of their governments, no matter who they elect. So, if I'm reading the situation correctly, when they seem to be "voting against their own interests" by voting unenthusiastically for a more rightist government, they may not actually be voting against their own interests at all. They may instead be acknowledging that they aren't going to get anywhere with any of the parties or their alternatives: the situation will stay the same or worsen no matter what party is in charge of the government because the government itself is a captured entity which the People cannot affect significantly from the inside.

The only real effect will come from the outside.

I may be projecting a great deal here, following my own twisted insights about these things, but maybe not. It may well be that people who seem to be voting against their own interests are dupes and fools; but it is quite as possible that they are making a strategic decision.

Watch what happens in Egypt as their Revolution is systematically undermined through legal and electoral shenanigans. Somehow, two weeks of agitation and occupation hasn't quite turned into the New Day the Revolutionaries thought it would. And after what the Egyptians have been going thorough since their "success" in overthrowing the Regime (oh yeah?) ,  the Arab Spring may not have been all it was cracked up to be.  A year later, it's looking to get even grimmer. And in Egypt, please note, the electoral process and candidate selection is as hamstrung as that of Iraq.

There is no way for the public interest and popular will to be appropriately acknowledged and expressed through these convoluted and highly managed electoral systems. While it is obvious in the case of the New Arab electoral situation -- elections are actually freer and produce a more representative outcome in Iran -- the shock of it is stronger because of the innocence and naivete of the electorate.

In sophisticated Europe, there is much less expectation that government will actually reflect the People's Will.

And here? Quien sabe? I think people are realizing -- if they hadn't already recognized it --  that elections are not the way toward significant policy changes. It simply won't happen -- because it can't.

How it will fall out, I don't know. We are in a Revolutionary Era, one unlike any I can point to in history because of its nearly universal aspect at the popular level, the nearly complete divorce between Peoples and their governments, and the extraordinarily widespread efforts of individuals and groups to engineer change from the ground up, without deference or reference to the ruling elites.

This is something different than Revolutions of the past.

There is a long way yet to go, but I suspect when the final act plays out, it will be quick. We'll see.

Sunday, June 17, 2012

Writing Greece Off



I think it was Ian Welsh who proposed to write off any people who failed to vote correctly and wound up with a Rightist government that made economic matters worse rather than improving things. Ah yes, here it is:


May 31 -- My Sympathy Is About Out

If the Irish vote in a referendum for austerity, then they deserve what they get.  Current polls are showing Greeks will probably vote for pro-austerity parties as well, if so, again, my sympathy will be out.  Democracy is about getting what you vote for, if countries vote for austerity, then they deserve it.


Well, that's putting it succinctly, isn't it?

The Irish did so vote. So did the Portuguese long ago. So did the Spanish. And now, so have the Greeks.

The Italians might have balked, but the Eurozone headed off that calamity by installing one of their own as PM, without a vote of the people. They tried the same trick in Greece, but it didn't quite work the first time around; now, apparently, there's little doubt.

Of course, we could go on about election fraud if we wanted to, and to the fact that SYRIZA came in a very creditable second. The Socialists, on the other hand, have been thoroughly discredited and look to become a rump or fringe party no matter.


The reason why? Of course, it's simple: the Socialists sold the People out. This has been happening all over Europe, and so rightist parties are surging. Think of what Tony Blair did to the Labour Party. Much the same has been happening everywhere.

The United States has never had a viable Socialist Party at the polls, and neither of our major political parties are even remotely Socialist. As I've said many times, Barack Obama's policies -- especially his economic policies -- are as if he is channeling Herbert Hoover, and I'm not the only one who says so. Yet he is accused of raging Marxism. It's absurd. But in the context of our own political firmament, understanding that the Democrats are what passes for a political "left" -- although there is nothing remotely leftist about them -- the Democrats are in the position of the sell-out Socialists of Europe, and the problem is that there is no... reasonable... political alternative there or here. The only alternative party capable of governing is the more rightist party.

The Greek "New Democracy" Party is not the fascists, at least not outwardly. Nor is SYRIZA the communists outwardly. So the Greek election results are not a huge break from the past or even a particularly portentous one. Instead, the Greeks have voted to continue with the current austerity policies but under somewhat harsher conditions for the People, much as the Spanish and Portuguese and Irish did.

That is if these election results are actually unfudged. We don't know. Also in Europe there are a number of competing parties and elections can be "won" on far less than a majority of the vote -- as was the case here. I was watching the official announcement of New Democracy's victory live this afternoon, and it was clear from the graphics, even though I neither read nor understand Greek worth mentioning, that ND "won" with less than 30% of the vote. SYRIZA was at 27.1%. PASOK (the Socialists) was 12.3%. The Nazis and the Communists each got around 7%. What's called the Independents weren't much more than that.

Even from an aggregate/coalition standpoint, there is no majority for a particular way forward, and to me, that's natural in a severe crisis situation. That's why so often nations in crisis turn to Leaders or leave themselves open to the blandishments of Leaders. The People on their own don't know what to do or more to the point, they don't see a way to proceed without a Leader in the vanguard.

One of the things about SYRIZA's candidate, Alexis Tsipris, was that he said that he wasn't ready to govern in any case. The honesty that he displayed all through the campaign apparently appealed greatly to the Greek People, but they weren't convinced -- as I wasn't -- that if he were to become the Prime Minister that he would... survive either politically or physically.

I predicted, for example, that if SYRIZA won a majority that a German-led coup would intervene to protect the bankers and their interests no matter what. No doubt the Greek People were more than a little aware of the potentials given the heavy propaganda from Berlin and Brussels and the open threats being made against the Greek People if they didn't vote the right way to please the banks and bankers. I expected that if SYRIZA won, Tsipris would be first against the wall, and that he would go willingly and would make quite a dramatic spectacle of it. But that would not have done a damn thing to make things better for the Greek People -- at least in the short term. Oh, but the Drama!

So. It's going to get worse. And I imagine Frau Merkel did a little dance to celebrate.

It isn't so much a matter of breaking the stranglehold of the Rightists and their sponsors and owners. As we've seen, in Europe, the Socialists are owned by the same banking interests. Going from one to the other keeps the People on the same dismal trajectory. Alternative political parties don't necessarily have the answer either.

The problem, as I see it, is that the "answer" -- such as there is one -- to government capture by the bankers and their cohorts is that it doesn't lie in elections and political parties. The answer lies outside a corrupt and potentially irredeemable system, which is one of the reasons why I find David Graeber's anarchist arguments so persuasive. He doesn't necessarily say pull down the system and install your own version; he says work around and sidestep it. Make it irrelevant.

I don't know that it can be done successfully on a large scale, though religious communities suggest it very much can. In fact, in some of the evangelicals/fundamentalists of today we have models for how to create parallel institutions and societies that are long lasting and serve parallel functions to those of government. It can be done, and American history is rife with examples.

So I don't agree with Ian's notion of writing off Peoples who vote the wrong way when they're given the opportunity -- as the Greek People were -- to vote something else again, something arguably better. They may or may not regret today's vote, but they are balancing enormous psychological pressures as well as economic catastrophe no matter what they do. Mitigating it to the extent possible seems to have been on their minds just as much as the need to find another way.

"Not as bad as those who have betrayed you" seems to be the universal declaration of the rightist parties like New Democracy.

"Not as bad as those who have betrayed you."

What a world.

What a world.

Bummer

New Democracy wins Greek elections. Let the looting, pillage, plunder and destruction continue.

Ee-haw.

The Obama Problem (Repost)

[I wrote this during the Debt Crisis Crisis. While I usually don't repost things from the past, it seems to me that Mr. Obama is struggling in the political arena once again, largely because people are dissatisfied with his performance on economic matters. The problem is his continued devotion to Hooverite economic principles. That's not to say that FDR and the New Deal were necessarily all that much better in an academic sense. They were far better in a political and popular sense. FDR understood the necessity of politically popular programs and policies, regardless of whether they were scientifically or academically sound; Hoover not so much, and not because he was such a bad man, or because he believed in "doing nothing" with regard to the economy -- neither was true about him.

No, the difference between Hoover and FDR, I think, was largely due to the fact FDR spent his entire adult life in politics and he came from a politically well connected and highly astute family. Hoover, not so much. Hoover was more of a bloodless technocrat, and the difference showed.

In the present case, of course, Romney has got Obama beat in the bloodless category. But Obama is obviously flailing as he goes around the country promoting economic policies that have actually resulted in an astronomical increase in unemployment and poverty. The People's answer is going to be, "NO!" There's no way around it.

The following essay written last July speaks of Obama as man of Principle whose primary Principle is that of Transcendence. And he will stick with it no matter what.]

The Obama Problem


I have from time to time offered both criticisms and defenses of His Serenity, Barack "Hoover" Obama -- mostly critical observation of what he is doing and why I think he's doing it. I don't think he is particularly evil or smart for that matter, but I do see him as increasingly self-possessed, self-actuated, and increasingly rigid in his core principles and beliefs.

President Carter with better looks and no Southern accent.

Well, yes. The Carter comparison has been raised since forever, on the presumption that Obama would be a one term president -- which he might well be, and I don't think he really much cares about that.

But lately, the fashion mavens in the Blogosphere have decided to push the notion that Obama is somehow The. Worst. President. Ever. (Excuse me, no.) Aware observers are more than willing to point out that the premise itself is stupid and unworthy, but it's hard not to succumb to the silliness because it is based in a human need to be on a "team" and support or defy the conventional wisdom.

Someone who supports his team feels validated, especially if his captain wins the game. And one thing I can say about Obama -- which I have in other fora -- is that he is a true believer in his own principles and his abilities to institute them through his agency as President.

His primary principle is that of Transcendence. He believes, truly, that it is his role to transcend the partisan divide, to bring the parties together, if not in harmony at least in agreement that something must be done and can be done, and to help hammer out whatever deal is necessary to Make It Happen.

That's what this Debt Crisis Crisis is all about. And it is -- sort of -- looking like he might pull it off.

Meanwhile, I came across a couple of considerations of The Obama Problem today that I think help clarify the picture. The first, via Digby, is by Michael Tomasky at the Daily Beast, and it is very good. The upshot is that Obama is doing what he is doing -- which often seems incomprehensible to observers -- because he really believes in the principle of transcendence and he is determined to stick with his principles no matter what.

He apparently really believes—still!—in civic-republican notions of government as an arena for reasoned deliberation. That he could still think this is akin to a child believing in Santa Claus until he’s 15—but apparently he does. The journalist Alec MacGillis captured this conviction well in a profile he did of Obama for the British New Statesman back in 2008. Barack Obama, he wrote, “was running not on a record of past achievement or on a concrete program for the future, but instead on the simple promise of thoughtfulness.” From this perspective a unilateral action would be almost impious—or at least, if you’d rather aim a little lower than God, anti-Madisonian. Obama would be giving up on his ideal. Of course he should have long since given up on it. I was with him at the beginning—his conviction that politics could be better and more deliberative was one of the things I found appealing about the man. But that ship sailed long ago, and Obama’s position has declined from admirable principle to indefensible fetish. Politics simply isn’t going to get better and more deliberative any time soon.
The third reason the president probably won’t do it is related to the second, but it’s more personal. Unilateral action would be at odds with Obama’s image of himself. In his article, MacGillis defined thoughtfulness Obama style as “the notion that the leadership of the country should be entrusted not on the basis of résumé and platform, but on the prospect of applying to the nation's problems one man's singularly well-tempered intelligence.” This is pretty obviously a dead-on description of Obama’s view of himself and his potential as president.


I think it is really a good description of what is going on. Of course Tomasky, like many others, is OUTRAGED!!!!™ and wants Obama to Stop This Nonsense Right Now!!! Yes, well. Good luck with that. At no point during his reign on the Throne has Obama shown even a hint of giving up his principles -- though he will cheerfully give up just about everything else.

The other Worst. President. Essay I read today was by Sterling Newberry via Ian Welsh. Sterling, gosh, goes back a long way, into the mists of Internet times, and he's always been an acute observer and analyst of what's happening. In today's essay at The Sorcerer's Apprentice he examines what is wrong, desperately wrong, with the Obama Reign, and I think he gets it mostly right.

I especially like his historical notes and this part:

The President who Obama most resembles is Herbert Hoover, another one of those chief magistrates of government who became inflexible and iron willed. His idea of compromise is that he cuts out what he thinks is a compromise, and then relentlessly grind on it. He's dealing with people whose idea of compromise is a woman having an orgasm while she is raped. Neither of these two sides have actually compromised very much, other than compromising on extending the Bush tax breaks for the wealthy.

Hoover was a malfortunate president. Unfortunate is not a sufficient adjective to describe it. He inherited an economy that was about to explode. He takes office in March of 1929, the move to January would, to no small extent be because the long gap between election and inauguration paralyzed the country when later he would lose the Presidency, and in October of 1929, the stock market plunges in what is know as "The Crash." In reality such a crash was essentially inevitable after the Olmstead Break in August. In effect he had 5 months of Presidency. The rest was a long grind and heavy flail. His response was not without compassion and, within his understanding, he worked hard to do what was right. He simply was a mammoth in a lake that had been swamped by a breaking glacier dam, to be found, frozen, as an oddity. His failure was that as his policies failed, he doubled and tripled down on them. In essence, he turned a single large downturn, into three back to back downturns, and left the very faith in capitalism and democracy bruised behind him.

FDR and Hoover had once been political friends, but his rants and threats, the most famous being his offer to let FDR be President early, if FDR would scrap the "so-called New Deal." FDR replied tartly that he was still a private citizen until inauguration, his term as Governor of New York having ended.


Like me and a number of others, Newberry is relating Obama to Hoover's presidency, and he explains why very well.

On the other hand, when it comes to the Debt Crisis Crisis, I think he is somewhat off the mark in that he doesn't seem to be able to relate it (or actually much of anything Obama has done) to Obama's principle of transcendence.

That's why I highlight both articles today: the one by Tomasky which gets into the underlying reasons why Obama is doing what he is doing -- though Tomasky is calling it wrong in all kinds of ways -- and Newberry's, take which relates Obama's actions with those of other Worst Presidents and takes him to task for missing so many opportunities to please The People (and his more leftward critics) by taking bold(er) and more authoritative/authoritarian action.

I honestly don't think Obama is doing what he is doing for political gain. He is doing it both because he can, and because he must. He is a believer, in other words, and a man of Principle. Unshakable Principle.

This is what Principled Governance looks like. It isn't pretty. And I don't think it is what we really want.

Saturday, June 16, 2012

The Greek Thing Continued


   
   
   
   
   


Though you wouldn't know it in this country, the media not working weekends and all, there will be a do-over Greek election tomorrow in which the radical left might eke out a victory -- yes, it really is a radical left over there, whereas in the United States, what passes for the "left" is composed of merely slightly less overtly radical rightists. It is widely assumed that no matter what the results of the Greek election are, some sort of jiggering of the enforced economic terms dictated on Athens from Berlin and Brussels will take place.

The fact that the Greek People are in extremis has not escaped notice either in Europe or in the rest of creation. That even greater levels of hardship are being demanded of the EuroPeriphery by the Core is widely recognized as self-defeating, and yet, there they go. As if it is the only thing they know. No matter what, the Greek -- and other Peripheral Peoples -- must be made to pay for the gambling losses of the major banks.

Bluntly put, this is how the colonial powers behaved toward their targets of opportunity back in the day. Much of the expansion of European colonial power was driven by very similar economic extortion. When the peoples to be subjected to colonial rule balked at the extortionate demands of the colonial powers -- demands that were made whether or not the to-be-colonized peoples were in debt to the colonial powers -- the colonial gunboats would commence shelling ports, the governmental palace (if there was one) was put to the torch, and members of the elite were rounded up and executed; a puppet of the colonists was put on the throne or in charge of the colonized sector, and the Europeans flocked in (though never in great numbers) to extract labor and resources from the cowed and terrorized People while piously nattering about Civilizing the Natives. Natives who were subject to extreme cruelty, brutality, sometimes genocide (let's talk about the Belgian Congo one day) famine, disease and massacre until they were "pacified" in service to their masters.

So now Frau Merkel and her assistants are trying to do it to Greece. That the Hellenes balk is of no account to her or to Mme Lagrand over at the IMF or to any of the other Core leaders. Hell no. Let them balk,  they can't do anything about the looting, plunder and pillage that is under way, let alone what is to come. They are as powerless as any other subject people. They have lost and they must pay.

Reversion.

It's the new "Forward!"

---------------------------------------------------------
Of course what's striking about this video documentary of the Greek healthcare system in mortal crisis is that these are the approximate conditions that millions upon tens of millions of Americans face all the time, indeed, which many more Americans can identify with even if they (still) have health care coverage.

Restricting access -- whether or not the patient has coverage -- has become the mantra of the field.


   
   
   
   
   



This

Digby posted this video of a colloquy at the New School between Chris Hayes (who has a Book Out, "Twilight of the Elites") and Katrina vanden Heuvel of the Nation magazine.

It's really very good.


Watch live streaming video from freespeechtv at livestream.com


I've liked vanden Heuvel for years now, though when I used to watch the Sunday Shows I found her to be far too reticent and "nice" in the context.

Hayes I've been more reserved about. He's obviously a careerist "public intellectual" -- whatever that truly is -- who's had a kind of meteoric trajectory from blogging to his own teevee show and whatnot. But his presentation here -- at least so far as I've seen it (I'm at 36 minutes in and must do some chores) -- is really spot on.

And that gets me to thinking: do I find his arguments sound because they sound right to an old fart like me, in other words because they are familiar, or because they are intrinsically sound?

I've been making the kinds of arguments about elites and institutions that Hayes does for many years. Now that someone in the Media is making similar arguments, does that make them right? Or...

Spend some time to hear what these two have to say. I haven't got to it yet, but the question period at the end is supposed to be very good as well.

Note, the video has about 3-4 minutes of dead time at the beginning as the speakers are apparently still in the green room. Some of those who tried to watch at Digby's apparently think the video is bad or that she posted the wrong link. Neither is true. If you have trouble with Livestream, though, this one probably won't work for you.




As Might Be Expected


As might be expected, the Imperial Ukase issued yesterday regarding the Deportation of Young Aliens has caused a bit of a ruckus in the Imperial Court. It has, they say, put the Republicans and Mr. Romney "on the spot." I'm sure it has. Not that it will likely matter in the end, but there you are.

As has been the case with many Emissions from On High, this latest Directive From the Throne is somewhat ambiguous and open to interpretation Down Below. Much like the multiple HAMP fiascos and the confusion surrounding other mortgage programs announced with great fanfare that wind up dashing rather than enhancing Hope, this one orders that DHS stop deporting "Dreamers" -- ie: students who through no fault of their own don't have immigration papers because they were brought to the US as children by undocumented immigrants. Other than that, of course, deportations can continue apace.

And what a pace it is, too. Millions have been sent packing into the Netherworld of Outer Darkness, some not surprisingly by mistake -- either they are legal immigrants or even citizens who get caught up in the Kafkaesque nightmare of a very brutal and totally unaccountable (to the People) bureaucracy which is apparently institutionally incapable of figuring out the most basic matters such as whether or not they should be deporting this or that individual, or even in some cases comprehending accurately who the individual is.

So now the Throne is declaring a halt to the deportation of undocumented students; that's going to work well, since their parents are still subject to random and arbitrary detention and deportation. As if breaking up families weren't bad enough as it is... And what was this about farmers and ranchers? I don't quite get it. Was he saying that illegal farmworkers are to be permitted so that farmers and ranchers can continue to exploit their labor or what? I actually think that's what he was getting at. "Because it's the right thing to do."

Yes, well.

On the other hand, I don't know that the Throne has control of DHS -- in fact, it doesn't look like anybody does. As was warned about at its creation, the Department has metastasized into a security behemoth that enjoys trampling all in its path and ignoring orders from On High. In fact, it seems to declare its independence from oversight and control every day, much like the CIA and such.

This is what happens when a massive security bureaucracy is instituted on the fly, under panic conditions, with a mandate but no realistic controls, oversight, or accountability for actions as opposed to meeting targets.

The US has had much experience with this sort of thing, and to see it happening again is sad. But the People have little or no say in these things, and Government is blind, deaf and dumb to persuasion from those who tend to get it right as opposed to those who tend to get it wrong.

So what will be the upshot of this move by His Serenity?

My sense? Much like many other domestic initiatives, little or nothing. ICE and DHS will continue to do whatever they damn-well please with regard to round ups and deportations; students will continue to be randomly selected for ejection; the brutal wheels of the Juggernaut will grind on, crushing all in its path.

And no one in a position to do anything about it will.

That's how Our Rulers want it to be, too.






Friday, June 15, 2012

A Wells Fargo Horror Story -- and an Update On The Van

Rousseau House in California, plundered by a series of banksters
I came across this story over at Naked Capitalism the other day, then I read that the homeowner had killed himself just days before the scheduled eviction in May. And I read the linked amended complaint.

And I thought "JFC on a merry go round, this is the most outrageous WF horror story yet." Almost beyond belief, and yet given all the other horror stories I've read, it's only unusual in that the homeowners had/have decent legal advice, and that the poor guy was driven to suicide.

Notice that the house above is quite a modest little house, similar to many I've been inside during parts of my working career. That the final refinance in 2007 was for over $350,000 is somewhat shocking, but that's what was still happening to real estate values in California at the time. In fact, I was dealing with a lot of builders, brokers and construction contractors during the boom before the crash, and by 2007, the warning signs were very clear that the crash was about to come, indeed had already come, in some cases that I can't detail here, but people were still refinancing and some were able to take cash out of their homes until well into 2008.

I say $350,000 is somewhat shocking for this house because in a realistic market it wouldn't be worth much over $200,000 if that. It's probably appraised for under that now, though WF ultimately acquired the house for a trustees sale bid of over $400,000.

So the homeowner was being screwed, whether or not there was fraud in the final refinance.

Nevertheless, according to the story, the homeowners were diligent in making mortgage payments. The problem came because they made those payments in person with cashier's checks at a Wachovia branch.

That and grossly false, misleading and predatory lending practices by World/Wachovia.

From the narrative in the amended complaint, the homeowners presented a cashiers check at the bank in April, 2009, in the amount of $1615, the stated mortgage payment amount. The check was handled by an employee who -- apparently -- entered a keystroke wrong during the transaction so that the check was not properly credited to the correct account. The homeowners received a receipt for the check and went on their way.

The next day, the check cleared, but what happened to the money is a mystery. There is also the mysterious claim of a stop payment being ordered on the check, which is simply not something that can happen on a cashiers check.

According to the complaint:

On or about May 5, 2009, while making the monthly payment at the WACHOVIA branch, Plaintiff O. ROUSSEAU the teller confirmed that their account still showed a missing payment for April. At Plaintiff’s request, Branch Manager PERI KERMANI called the corporate office to inquire about the disputed payment. Plaintiff was given a facsimile number to send a written dispute and proof of payment.
Which Plaintiffs (the homeowners) did.

From then on, the situation deteriorated alarmingly. While the homeowners continued to be diligent about making payments until the bank refused to accept them, they were dicked around and lied to by bank personnel constantly throughout a torturous process of trying to rectify the erroneous April "delinquency." They submitted all the documentation necessary to clear the supposed "delinquency" and never once did the bank actually clear it, though they were told it had been taken care of. They were assessed more and more collection fees, NSF fees, a constant tidal wave of fees while they not only tried to straighten out the mess the bank had caused, they were attempting to get their loan modified because of loss of income due to unemployment.

 As has so often been the case, while they were attempting to get the loan modification, the bank was proceeding with foreclosure, which the homeowners tried to get them to stop but were unsuccessful. Meanwhile, even as the bank was refusing to accept offered mortgage payments, they were constantly calling and dunning the homeowners for payment.

As has so often been the case, while attempting to secure a loan modification, the homeowners were repeatedly told that required documents had not been received -- though they had been sent over and over again -- and thus they could not get the modification, and then, apparently, the missing documents would somehow be found and the modification process would supposedly continue only to stop again.

Meanwhile, the foreclosure process churned along, oblivious.

Finally, from what I gather, the homeowners were denied a modification and told to pay up the arrears or get out. By the time they found out how much they had to pay to satisfy the largely bogus debt that was caused by a bank error in the first place, they had one hour to meet a deadline to deliver more than $26,000 demanded to the bank's collection agency in Texas. They had the money, but they couldn't meet the deadline because they couldn't access that much at one time given cash withdrawal restrictions on the account in question.

Wells Fargo acquired the property at a trustees sale purportedly held November 22, 2010, five days after the homeowners were told how much to pay and given a deadline they couldn't meet to satisfy the alleged default. At the time of the court filing, dated January 11, 2011, WF was under temporary injunction from enforcing an unlawful detainer against the Rousseaus. Apparently the injunction was lifted in May of 2012, and the Rousseaus were informed that they would be evicted on May 15, 2012; two days beforehand, when Norman Rousseau was unable to complete repairs on the engine of a motorhome that the couple intended to move into once they were evicted, Mr. Rousseau fatally shot himself.

All because a teller at Wachovia failed to credit the correct account for a payment made in April of 2009 and no one at any of the participating financial institutions and collection agencies between then and the date of Norman Rousseau's suicide had the courage or the brains to recognize that the bank had made a simple -- and not uncommon -- mistake that could have been and should have been easily corrected years before Norman Rousseau took his own life.

That and all the appalling fraud and deceit that went into the Rousseau's final refinance.

And all the lies they were told and the promises that were broken.

And the many tens of thousands of dollars that were being pillaged and looted all along the way.

This is a snapshot of a completely brainless and totally out of control modern banking practice. I'm sure that none of the institutions or people involved on the banking end believe they actually did anything wrong or that they are in any way responsible for the Rousseau's agony and eventually for Norman Rousseau's suicide. They never think that way. They can't. There are no personal relationships at all in these situations. Everything is objectified and scripts and flowcharts rule. "If this, then that." There is no provision for acknowledging or correcting errors, even simple ones such as mis-keying a payment.

As has long been obvious, all of the incentives for banks and mortgage servicers are aligned toward pushing homeowners into foreclosure. Despite ostensible programs to prevent foreclosure, the financial and corporate-bureaucratic incentives are still toward foreclosure. Consequently, millions of people are still losing their homes every year when it is highly likely that foreclosure is actually the least desirable outcome not just for the homeowner but for everyone involved including the banks and servicers who are incentivised to foreclose.

How many of these cases are due to fraud at the outset, errors along the way, and corporate-bureaucratic blindness is anybody's guess, but I am sure the Rousseau's situation is not unique. I've read too many similar stories.

It's one reason I was an advocate long ago for the nationalization of the banks; they are simply too hidebound, blind and dumb to function on behalf of even themselves let alone on behalf of the People in the current financial climate.

They should be run strictly in the public interest for the duration.  But until somebody with clout picks up that cudgel, we'll continue to encounter tragic stories like that of the Rousseaus.

None of this has to happen.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
As for the van, I spent part of the morning in Atwater discussing options with repair folks face to face instead of on the phone. I also drove the van for a short distance, and it was obvious that it wasn't going to make it much farther at all. I got it to the repair shop across the street from where I had left it last Saturday, and when the proprietor saw me drive up and said: "You've got a transmission problem." He explained how he had come to that conclusion when Omar at the first shop had brought the van over for a diagnosis on Monday. I asked about the differential. He said he didn't drive the van, but all the sound he heard when the van was on the lift was coming from the transmission and he thought there was metal on metal (oh yes) requiring a rebuild. I asked him whether he could do it, how soon he could have it ready, and how much he'd charge. He said he most certainly could do it; probably take until until Wednesday of next week, and it would cost X number of dollars (a good deal less than I was anticipating.)  I said, "Let's do it."

The vans that I had been considering as replacements were either sold before I could get to them or they were inappropriate for my needs; as I've said, this red Astro van has been a very good friend on the road for a number of years now. I bought it specifically for the trips back and forth between New Mexico and California, and despite the occasional mechanical problem and infrequent breakdown, it has been a godsend and a jewel. And then I think how lucky I am to be able to write that last sentence at all.

So many Americans don't have the option to just go out and "buy a van" or have it repaired as needed let alone to have a second home in New Mexico to go back and forth to. Those are just a few of the examples of the privileges we have. And when I think about the real struggles so many Americans are facing, struggles that are so far beyond my minor inconveniences (in perspective a broken down van or stalled refinancing are minor inconveniences, yes) I'm humbled.

The Rousseau's story is devastating. That sort of thing is happening to way too many Americans, and there seems to be nothing to thwart the demons of destruction abroad in the land.

Rise up, resist, refuse. It's a start!


Wednesday, June 13, 2012

This And That

 

Somewhat overextended I am right now.

The van is still in Atwater; the really very nice people at the repair shop say they have repaired "the big noise," but there's still a "little noise" that they can't diagnose -- may be transmission, may be differential, but they aren't sure. They said they drove it to another shop, had them look at it there, got the information that it is either/or, then drove it back to the first shop and it was driving fine. "Just this little noise..." OK, say I.

Problemo.

I wouldn't be surprised if it is both transmission and differential. Which means it may be time to retire the van -- which, by the way, has been a loyal friend on the road for a long time.

Getting back to Atwater without a vehicle of my own is something of a challenge -- not impossible, but a challenge nonetheless (there's a train to Merced and it's about 8 miles from the Amtrak station to Atwater.) But if, as I suspect, I really can't drive the van back to whence it came, just getting down there is kind of useless. So...Pondering options. I'm kind of inclined to go check out a similar van available out in the suburbs but getting there without a vehicle of my own, I'm finding, takes longer than taking the train to Merced would. Isn't that something? Public transportation: Good luck, sucker!

Meanwhile, at the same time, I'm trying to work through refinancing our mortgage in New Mexico... and what fun that is, given that it is all long distance via phone and email. I'm working with a couple of lenders: Wells Fargo, which holds our current mortgage, and another I'll not name at this point, but which we may be going with. Terms proposed are similar, and though with the new lender the process is more complicated, it will take much less time to complete the refinancing with them than with WF. As the broker says about why it takes so long with WF: "It's Wells Fargo." And when I think about the months it took to get the mortgage financing package from them in the first place (We put a deposit on the house in August of 2005; we did not close on the mortgage until January of 2006) it's not all that surprising that a refinance would take almost as long and conceivably longer. Oh, and the WF horror stories I've read. Heartbreaking. They're almost all the same: promises made; promises broken; paperwork lost, over and over and over and over and over and over and over again; last minute document demands from the bank; last minute denial in processes that stretch out for months and months and months. In some cases, it's a matter of sales taking priority over service (it's a bank, you know), and in others, it's clearly a matter of deliberate cruelty, because WF never intends to provide mortgage refinancing or modification at all. They seem to just want to hold the customer tight and take various fees along the way -- for appraisals primarily, which in some cases are never actually done.

From what I can tell from the testimonies (I've seen hundreds by now), people get lured in by WF sales pitches ("Low Rates! Refinance Now! Mortgage Modifications! We have Programs!") and are sold something they actually can't qualify for. Once they are sold, the loan agent forgets about them, never submits the documents -- which is why they get "lost" over and over again -- until the last minute, knowing that the rubes are going to be declined or get screwed. It seems to be such common practice at the Big Banks that the personnel don't even think about it any more. It's just business as usual for them. Completely vile.

On the other hand, I have found only one complaint about the alternate lender we're working with -- and that complaint was through the BBB which does not disclose details. One complaint. We'll research court cases to make sure that this record is accurate. The broker we're working with is a little harried, but she follows up, seems to be very forthcoming and up front, and is essentially a neighbor in NM (next town over.) Costs are a little higher with that lender than what WF is proposing, but you know what? I tend not to believe much of anything WF says these days...

Meanwhile, the rest of the household at Casa Ché is preparing to retire at the end of the month and we are packing up for the Final Move to New Mexico (prep for which I was headed to NM to take care of when the van broke down).

It's quite a basket of challenges and activity for an old coot and sometime radical like me.

I'm busy and sometimes kind of frantic. But the situation has helped me realize (again) how fundamentally lucky I am to have these challenges to work through as best I can. To learn from. Perhaps to help others from what I've learned. You never know.

Often I find myself in a quandary and dilemma between the vanilla middle-classness of much of my lifestyle and the call to rebellion, challenge and adventure that has characterized so much of my life. I'm face to face with that quandary right now, being pulled in several directions at once, and all sorts of things seeming to be popping out of some alternate universe to claim my attention and say "Hay! What about this! And that! And the other thing!"

One of the class of challenges that we'll be facing once the whole Ché household is retired is that we will be without health insurance for a while -- a few months in the case of one of us, a little over a year in the case of myself. We are not going to use the COBRA option, which is close to $3,000 a month to maintain our current coverage, and there is no paid health care plan included in the retirement package. There are options to purchase, but none are less than $1,100 a month. Even with Medicare, the supplements offered through the retirement system are breathtakingly expensive. So when people start bellyaching about all the benefits public sector retirees get, they need to check some facts rather than succumb to the propaganda of the media. Most pensions are based on years of service and contributions by employer and employee; there has never been a free ride for most public employees; they have always been contributing to their pensions. Furthermore, they have voluntarily -- in recent years involuntarily -- taken significant pay cuts and/or foregone scheduled increases, thanks to generous Union Bosses who always seem to see their own nests feathered very nicely indeed. Yes, indeed. (Their argument: "It could be worse, yanno.")

Many public employees never work long enough to reach the point where they qualify for a pension at all, or they work in categories that aren't covered. This has become more commonplace as budgets are cut and most new hires are temps -- some of which remain temps for years and years. And years. They might not even qualify for healthcare coverage or have to pay huge premiums once they do qualify. And this out of salaries that are being constantly reduced. I have been a public employee or contractor from time to time over my working career. My longest stretch as a public employee was 11 years. I decided to take my retirement in a lump sum when I left. I received -- let me look it up, they sent me a 1099-R -- $632.73. From which they withheld $126.55 in taxes. To assert -- as the propagandists constantly do -- that public employees are all somehow privileged over private sector employees is to be deliberately deceptive or obtuse. And the idea that it is somehow "just" to cut anyone's salary or benefits in this economy is akin to economic suicide.

Yes, there are a few people who are doing very well in the public sector, oh my yes. And they will retire with 6 figure incomes, in some cases higher than their base pay was, and they'll get full health care coverage on top of it and probably all kinds of other perks as well. Whether or not they deserve it is beside the point. They negotiated whatever it is they receive in salary and perks and benefits, and whatever it is, it is much less than that of those at the top of the private sector pyramid. In the areas I'm most familiar with, salaries top out at a little over $100,000; most workers think they are doing well if they get $35,000. Many earn much less. Starting salaries are pitiful, not much higher than minimum wage. If they work long enough to get a pension at all, it will amount to no more than 60% or so of their final wage, and in some categories, they won't get Social Security. We're not talking Big Bucks except at the very top of the public sector pyramid, and even those bucks aren't that big when compared to the retirement packages of CEOs.

On the other hand, just the fact that public employees still have any kind of defined benefit retirement packages at all is enough to set off the claxons of the propaganda machine every few minutes. I know this since I am in a capital city, and the local (McClatchy) paper has had a never-ending propaganda campaign against public employees, their unions and especially their pensions. It's relentless and every day. It's been going on for years, through good times and bad; and why not? They broke their own unions and decimated their pension funds years ago. Why not go after the public sector, too? While they like to yammer ad infinitum over the Big Ticket public pension "scandals" what they are really going after -- it's obvious -- is the pittance the lowly long-time employee might get after 30 years. They cannot stand the notion that a lowly state or local government worker who has been drudging all these years -- often berated and thanklessly -- might get 50% or 60% of their salary when they retire.

Since private sector workers get nothing -- even if they put money by in their worthless 401ks or looted IRAs -- why should public employees get anything?

This is completely backwards thinking.

And that kind of thinking has characterized the whole economic policy discussion since well before the crash. It only intensified afterwards.

EVERYONE should receive a decent retirement income; it shouldn't even be a controversial topic. EVERYONE should receive healthcare coverage automatically -- yes, of course they would pay for it through taxes. That shouldn't be controversial, either.

The correct way to address the banking and financial crisis was to provide household debt relief from the first, so that creditors could be paid off from the bottom up. Instead all the relief went directly to the banks; oops, nothing left for the people!

It's all so screwed up thanks to the perverse ideologies of the few that have been sold to the many like cotton candy.


But I ramble and I'm late for an appointment...
-------------------------------------------------------------
UPDATE: Had a long chat with the Wells Fargo loan agent soon after posting this; she was almost abject about Wells Fargo's horrendous reputation for bad customer service. Of course she said Bank of America is worse! Yes, well, that's not exactly an endorsement is it?

The "problem" she said is in Modifications, not Refinance (I disputed this), and she said that she would NEVER ask us for documents we had already submitted if something went missing during underwriting, because she would have copies of everything, and if there was a need for something we had already submitted, she would produce and provide it from her files.

She said it would not take more than 90 days if we act now (there is another program on the horizon, she said, for FHA loans, and that's going to cause another backlog in the Refinance Department... ) It would probably be much less than 90 days, and she'd try to get it done much quicker by "pushing" the Underwriters and Processors. I asked her where they were. She said she thinks they're in Arizona but she's not sure.

In addition, she pointed out that having Wells Fargo do the refinancing is much simpler than doing it through another lender because they already have the mortgage file and don't have to create a new one. She almost claimed that another lender couldn't do it at all. I said, "Yes, it is so simple, it literally takes only a few minutes to complete the required forms." She disputed that, saying that they have to get an appraisal (actually, it may not be necessary, but they want one anyway) and they have to do the usual due diligence to confirm sources of income and such, so it takes longer than "a few minutes" to complete the underwriting. But yes, she agreed, it is "simple" for the originating bank. The only reason it takes so long to close a refinance is that there are so many of them to be done. Another lender essentially has to start from the ground up, and may wind up unable to do the refinance in the end.

She was she said determined to demonstrate to us that Wells Fargo's refinancing customer service was among the best in the business, and promised to stay on top of our loan through the entire process. I pointed out that we got the same promises when we originally financed through Wells Fargo and it took 5 months to close and the interest rate was 2% higher than we had been told it would be. When we questioned the loan officer about it, she claimed it was the going rate for that kind of loan (purchase and renovation), regardless of what we had been told when we first applied for the mortgage. So I wasn't really going to take anything that Wells Fargo had to say at face value.

LATER: I got a call from the other lender's broker. And we talked for a long time. During the day, we'd been emailing about retirement and other issues, and finally she sent an email saying that she couldn't "start" the process until after the last day of the month because of the retirement income issue. Whoa. This actually would amount to a one month delay in "starting" the process. I was stunned and said so.

She said even if she "started" now -- by submitting full documentation to the extent we have it -- everything would stop as soon as the underwriters made contact with the employer because there would be confirmation not of employment for the next six months but of retirement at the end of the June. In order to get past that roadblock, we would need to submit an Award Letter, which we can't get until at least the end of June, so there really wasn't any point in submitting the other documents now since underwriting can't proceed without confirmation of retirement income and it will still take the same length of time to get the loan underwritten once the Award Letter is submitted as it would if we started now. She says once we have all required documentation in place (the only thing missing is the Award Letter so far as we know) then the process will take just about 24 days to closing. She said that if something required for underwriting is missing, the process stops, and the application has to go through Underwriting again.

Rather than take that risk, she said it would be better to gather all the required docs and submit them all at once.

During the day, I'd been researching the HARP refinance guidelines and Freddie Mac "Seller's Guide," and sure enough, it is more difficult for another lender to do the refinancing because they have to create a whole new mortgage file and have to follow much stricter underwriting rules to get it approved for purchase -- in this case by Freddie Mac. With Wells Fargo, they and we have already met most of the underwriting requirements and don't have to go through the whole process again (for example, we're assumed to be creditworthy, and as the house already has an appraisal from the first mortgage it isn't absolutely necessary to get one again -- though Wells Fargo wants one anyway.)  But in the case of either Wells Fargo or a new lender, they must verify source of income. In other words, the process cannot go forward for either lender without an Award Letter. So that's going to be the sticking point no matter what.

 Also, we did some more extensive court searches for complaints against our alternative lender, and there were literally none. Zero. Nada. This contrasts with HUNDREDS of complaints against Wells Fargo. They're practically every day.

It's all fascinating...




Sunday, June 10, 2012

Would A President Romney Actually Be Worse Than Another Term of President Obama?

Romney wants so much to serve you
The answer is "Yes." That should be obvious. President Romney would be worse than President Obama in approximately the same way that George W Bush was worse than a President Gore would have been.

Bush's legacy -- if you want to call it that -- will live in infamy while Gore has petered out to near irrelevance in the public mind. Millions were slaughtered or displaced during the Bush era, imperialist aggression was launched, torture instituted as widely known policy (though continually officially denied), civil liberties were sharply curtailed, whole cities suffered ruin and neglect at home and abroad, and so on, all orchestrated, dictated if you will, from the White House. These things were not accidents.

For all his wardrobe and other faults, President Gore is unlikely to have done those things.

As is well known, the terrible things that Bush initiated or expanded during his time in the White House have largely continued under Obama, and Obama has built on the Bush/Cheney structure of rule. Rather than wars of opportunity and aggression, though, Obama prefers stealth Death From Above of "targeted" militants, insurgents, "enemies" of all kinds. He prefers arrests and draconian charges against domestic dissenters and whistleblowers. Civil liberties may be less openly suppressed, but efforts to curb and suppress dissent are no less intense. He prefers to let bygones be bygones with regard to the appalling crimes against humanity of his predecessors in office, and he has much the same attitude toward the banksters who crashed the economy and continue to loot, plunder and pillage with abandon.

It is unlikely that any of those things would change under President Romney. But what would change is this: domestic "order" would be compelled. Revenge is likely to be a paramount motivation for domestic policies. Harm would be no less widespread than it is now, but reward for faith and loyalty would be much greater because there will be more to offer those who are faithful and loyal.

The economic situation for most Americans will not get better; it will stay the same or get demonstrably worse. But there might be a greater sense of "hope" among the suffering masses. Instead of the languid indifference toward their plight as demonstrated time and again by the Obama regime, Romney in office would be constantly talking about the plight of the Lesser People while doing nothing to alleviate it. What would be likely for the poor and unemployed, maybe the homeless and mentally ill as well, is a form of indenture, by which they are provided with some sort of unpaid employment (which they are required to take) in exchange for bare and basic necessities of living, and perhaps forced instruction in thrift and obedience. In other words, don't be surprised if President Romney initiates a whole different order of society for the poor, homeless and mentally ill -- those who "can't make it" -- as opposed to the social order for those who can and do. Make it, that is.

There seems to be a natural point at which the current decline in living standards will begin to mitigate: it's about when 20% lives in poverty, and the 80% remainder feel they have escaped the worst of the Endless Recession. We're not quite there yet, as public employees continue to be shed and the official poverty rate is still slightly under 20%. But once it gets there, which will probably happen no matter who is in office, expect to see the beginnings of economic stabilization for the masses. The economic theory will be that so long as The 80% are doing OK, The Suffering 20% don't matter. They should be Grateful. As long as they're kept in a kind of spare but useful servitude, why should they complain anyway?

They'd be doing something useful for Their Betters. And what would Their Betters be doing under President Romney that they aren't doing now? For one thing, positions of wealth and power would become much more hereditary than they are now, and a true aristocracy of breeding would be instituted and promoted much more widely than we currently see, with Willard as the prime example of the Son following the Father in Power (and Glory if you like).

There would continue to be elections of a sort, but positions would become quasi-officially hereditary in far more cases than now.  That would be unlikely in the extreme to occur under President Obama, though a mostly non-hereditary aristocracy would continue as customary.

Elections would become more farcical, but probably would be taken more seriously, than they are now. Whether there would be so much money dumped into elections would depend on how useful the media chooses to be to the New Settlement Regimes*.

For the money expended in campaigns is almost all fed directly into the maws of media conglomerates, in other words, Plutocracy feeding itself. The economic ideal is for the stronger to exploit the weaker, however, and among Plutocrats and Oligarchs, open exploitation of one another for someone else's profit is not polite. Never mind that the media money is spent to propagandize the masses. Shouldn't they be paying for their own brainwashing? I mean really.

That would mean that campaign money as we've known it would begin to disappear, and taxpayer funded elections might become standard. Of course that couldn't happen until the tax burden is fully shifted off of wealth and onto the middling and poor where it belongs. Taxes, after all, are punishment for failure. Those who do not achieve wealth are ipso facto failures, and only they should be subjected to the compulsion of taxation. Their Betters, on the other hand, will be offered opportunities for voluntary contributions of -- say -- as much as 10% of their income to worthy public causes, or even to the government if they choose.

As now, candidates would still be chosen by Their Betters for the masses to vote for, but the likelihood of insurgent candidates would be reduced to near absence. Elections would be formalities of popular approval for the pre-chosen few.

Eligibility to vote will be further restricted, perhaps only to those who have proved themselves worthy of citizenship and the franchise.

There might be other public rituals besides elections, probably on the pattern of public rallies at stadia and arenas and so forth that will be intended to "build community" and break the strangle-hold of devices and teevee on people's attention and leisure.

While this is a feature Obama might have instituted, given the huge crowds he was drawing during the 2008 campaign and the millions who gathered to freeze in the Mall while he was inaugurated, he quickly set out to disabuse the People that he was there to do anything for them; if anything, Obama policies set out to out Hoover Hoover. Consequently, gathering such enormous crowds now is essentially impossible for him now.

But a Romney Regime would not be holding such rallies for him as such, they would be clearly intended to build a sense of common purpose and community among attendees, more like the patriotic rallies of the past.

Internationally, I suspect that after wiping out Iran -- which seems more and more inevitable at some point, much as the Alexandrian effort to destroy the Persian Empire seems inevitable in hindsight -- all foreign interest will turn to China, or rather turn on China, in an American led effort to cripple and recolonize the Celestial Empire.

Of course this may turn into a long term and ultimately futile campaign which may so debilitate the United States that it... disappears, broken into petty statelets, the remainder partially absorbed by Canada and Mexico.

Don't laugh.

The United States has unfulfilled atonement to make, according to Romney's Mormon Scripture, and further, the Mormon Temple Romney was endowed into -- and in which he is still styled a bishop -- once demanded revenge against the United States for the murder of the Prophet Joseph Smith and his brother Hyrum. Of course they disavow any such thing now, and they say they have not included it in Temple Endowment ceremonies since 1927, but the Oath of Vengeance from previous generations was operative when Romney was Endowed at a Temple ceremony in 1966.

Whether or not a President Romney would consciously seek vengeance on the United States on the basis of that oath is something I think only he would know, but the Mormon church has an intrinsic sense of animus toward the United States government for its interference in and persecution of religious practices, some of which, like polygamy, forced Romney's grandfather to settle his polygamous family in exile in Mexico rather than put up with US government interference. This is not ancient history. For many Mormons, and for all I know the Romneys as well, this is very recent.

Despite all the accusations to the contrary, it's clear that Obama is not actively trying to take vengeance on or otherwise destroy the United States as such -- though his policies largely aid the Overclass in destroying the American People's wealth and security, the American People have often been considered expendable in some cause of the Rich whether it be war, empire, or economic peril for the masses. Obviously, Romney's predatory and parasitical capitalist career at Bain is not in any way outside the norm for his class.

There may be something deeper in both men's views of past (or present) slights and persecutions, but if so, it's not obvious. So I wouldn't be focused on the potential for mayhem implicit in the Mormon Oath of Vengeance. It may or may not even be a factor in a Romney presidency.

What we should keep in mind is that this nation has a deeply rooted theocratic underpinning. Its tendency has always been more or less toward theocracy, not toward secularism and pluralism. Thus, an antagonistic theocratic state like Iran would be considered an existential threat -- even though it is not -- because its theocracy competes with America's own. An overtly secular and atheistic state like China (or the former Soviet Union for that matter) is seen as an existential threat -- even though it is not -- because successful secular/atheist societies compete with America's theocratic-tending state.

No matter whether Romney or anyone else in office thinks and acts directly from a position of religious authority, the result is essentially the same because of the nature of the American state, not because of the nature or religious beliefs of the person in office.

Yes, a Romney presidency would be worse that Obama's in the same way George W Bush's presidency was worse than Gore's might have been, yet none of them are particularly good for the People of the United States due to the nature of its founding, its Constitution, and the state itself.

Bad can easily become worse.
-----------------------------------------------------------
*[Forgot my footnote!] "New Settlement Regime" is a term coined to describe the means by which the financial shenanigans of the Highest of the Mighty are rationalized and backstopped by governments. As used by me, however, I'm referring to the New Settlement Regime as the ruling corporatocracy itself, as exemplified by one of its members, Mr. Romney of Bain Capital. In other words, the corporatocracy would be rationalizing and backstopping itself through direct extraction and rule.


Saturday, June 9, 2012

100 Miles



Another aborted trip to New Mexico today. There have actually been very few aborted trips in the last 30 years or more, a couple of times when other duties interfered, and a couple of times -- like today -- in which vehicle problems made the trip impossible.

Today, I got a hundred miles down the Central Valley, as far as Atwater, when a loud grinding noise started coming from the rear of the van. Had to stop. Luckily, I was near an exit from the freeway, and there was a convenient parking lot next to an O'Reilly's auto parts store where I pulled in and called AAA.

They couldn't find an open repair shop in Atwater, bless their hearts for trying. I told them I'd try to find one and call them back. I checked with the people inside the O'Reilly's -- and we had a good laugh because the staff had mostly just started working there and they were transferred from other locations to this one. One of them said, "I could tell you what's open in Merced, but I don't know anything about Atwater." Another went to check with the manager and said there was a place called Tony's on the other side of the freeway overpass, to the right. Wasn't sure whether it was open on Saturday or not, but it would be worth a try.

It didn't seem like a very long hike, so I decided to go scouting. Did not find a place called "Tonys" but did find a place called "Moore's" (which was closed) and another across the street which was open.

Spoke to the woman there and she said they could stay open while the van was towed to the shop; if they could diagnose and repair today, they would. Otherwise, they would have to wait till Monday, but I could leave the van.

Well, sure. Why not? I told her where it was and I would have it towed; process would probably take forty-five minutes to an hour. She thought that would be fine.

So, the van was picked up and towed to the shop, and almost as soon as I managed to get it into the service bay -- watched by a crowd of onlookers -- the shop closed for the rest of the weekend. I laughed.

Meanwhile, I'd arranged to be picked up and transported the 100 miles north to where I'd started from.

It was an adventure. It really was. I don't know what's wrong with the van. It may be transmission, differential, wheel bearings, catalytic converter or all of them or none of them. It's an old van and things go wrong with it, usually reparable without too much trouble but for the mighty expense, and we go on.

Though the saga of the van is an adventure in its own right -- the stories I and it could tell! -- it was the people I encountered along the way and what was happening to them that truly grabbed me. Made me think. And in many ways, made me grateful.

First it was the people at O'Reilly's who clearly wanted to help, but they were so new to the area they weren't able to provide more than very sketchy guidance. While I was walking over the freeway to see if I could find "Tony's", I passed a number of teen boys walking purposefully in the opposite direction. They were somewhat giddy, and I nodded a greeting as they passed. They smiled. One said, "Hello." Not much farther on, I passed by a number of teen girls shouting at drivers to come get their cars washed! I couldn't see where they were washing cars, although there was a self-service car wash just up the street. I was surprised at the amount of traffic; this was a sparsely ornamented but very busy section of town. As I turned south at the second stop light, I encountered a couple of people sitting on concrete benches under canopies at a local transit stop. There was a middle aged woman -- I nodded to her -- and a late-teen boy enraptured by one of those devices that everyone has these days. He paid no attention to me at all.

The people at the car repair place, customers and staff alike, were mostly Spanish-speaking, and my halting Spanish got a few stares. I never know whether native Spanish speakers stare because it's still so unusual for an Anglo to try to speak Spanish, or because I mangle the language so badly. At any rate, despite the stares, they were very friendly and let me know they would do what they could; if it meant they couldn't do anything until Monday, at least the van would be safe inside.

As I headed back to the site where I'd left the van, I passed the same woman and the teen boy at the transit stop and nodded to the woman again; she smiled. I don't think she was waiting for a bus, but maybe she was. The boy was still engrossed in his device. I called AAA as I walked, telling them of the repair shop I'd found and asking them to send a tow truck. The teen girls were still shouting at drivers to come get their cars washed. I thought that was a little silly because the wind was very high and there was much dust in the air. Atwater is in the midst of the Central Valley's agricultural area, and dust was being kicked up for miles all around, in some places thick enough to obscure vision. Right where I was, the dust was noticeable but wind was the main problem.

As I walked north, I saw two women up ahead walking with several children, one in a stroller, in the direction I was going. They were going slow because of the wind. They turned west and I followed, catching up with them at the second stop light where we were all going to cross the street. As we crossed with the walk light, vehicles intending to make a left turn onto that street waited. Most did. One didn't, a large pick up (I think it was a Dodge Ram)  driven by a seemingly oblivious not young but not old man decided not to wait and nearly ran into one of the children walking with the group. One of the women started shouting at the driver, cursing and otherwise berating him, and I said to the other woman, "That was scary; he wasn't paying any attention at all." She said, "He could have hit the girl." The girl said, "Shouldn't we do something?" The other woman said, "Yeah, get out of the street before they run us down." She shouted at the driver, "Pedestrians have the right of way, you know!" She called him a name but I didn't hear it. The man stuck his head out the window and said, "I saw you; I never got that close to you. You don't have to shout and curse like that."

The woman said, "You nearly ran over my daughter!" She called him a name again. The girl said, "Yeah."

The other woman said to me, "I've never seen anything like it. This is completely crazy." I agreed.

We had the right of way. Not just because we were pedestrians in a crosswalk, but because the light was in our favor, starting to count down as we reached about midway across the street. The woman I was talking to said that though we had the right of way and the walk light was in our favor, the cars wanting to turn left onto that street also had a green arrow. Some of them obviously didn't know the rules of the road, though. Nevertheless, we made it across through the clot of cars and continued on our way.

I managed to get back to the van well before the arrival of the tow truck. The tow truck driver was jolly as they usually are when they show up to help with one of my vehicles in distress. Since the van was in a marked parking place, he said we'd have to push it to get it into position to tow it. He wanted me to sit inside and turn the wheel while he pushed. With the engine off, of course, turning the steering wheel was no easy task, and I was turning it the wrong way anyway. He said, "No, no, no, not that way, the other way, I want to load it from the front." He came over to help me turn the steering wheel the other way, and I said, "You know, if I start the engine, this will be a lot easier."

"You can start it?!" he said, amazed.

"Oh yeah," I said, "I bet I can even drive it to where you need it to be to load onto the truck. I shouldn't drive any distance, though, because of that grinding noise."

He was thrilled. I started the van and drove it the twenty feet or so needed to position it for loading. I could hear the grinding noise, but the tow truck driver said all he heard was the catalytic converter rattling.

He loaded the van onto the truck very efficiently and fast, and I got in the truck while he got ready to drive us to the repair shop. He had the address wrong, but I told him the name of the place, and he knew approximately where it was. Suddenly though, he leaped out of the truck and opened the hood. He jiggled with some wires, came to look at what I thought was a GPS device, then closed the hood. He said, "Damn computer's always going out!" I laughed.

Maneuvering around the parking lot and then the roads to get to the freeway overpass was like a game of Chutes and Ladders; I had never seen such a complicated set of not well connected parking lots and roadways. Living in an urban area in California and a rural one in New Mexico has got me used to straight streets (more or less) that meet at right angles (more or less), where one can get from place to place with relative ease. We were dealing with something completely different in this recently developed freeway commercial area of Atwater.

These new-fangled streets curve in all directions, they do not meet at right angles -- if they meet at all -- and it is impossible to make a left turn from most parking lots or streets into any other. Right turns from parking lots or streets are liable to get you face to face with dilemmas you never thought you'd face, because if you don't already know the route to your destination, you're liable not to find it.  At least not easily.

The driver did find his way, though, and soon enough we were at the repair shop, a modest crowd awaiting us.

The driver pulled up at the side of the building while I went in to see where they wanted the van. The woman said they were going to move some of the vehicles in front, and if the driver could park in front, it should be easy enough to get the van into the shop. We discussed it with the driver, and it didn't seem like that was going to work, because the street in front was very busy, and the truck would be facing the wrong way. The woman said the driver could actually drive onto the sidewalk, and when I said that to him, he said, "Nooooo!" It was very narrow, too narrow for his truck, and I could see how dangerous it was. She asked me if I could drive the van, and I said for a short distance, yes. She said that if the driver left the van on the street right where he'd parked, I could then drive it onto the sidewalk and into the shop.

This we agreed was the correct plan. The van was deposited at the curb and I started it up. There was no grinding, just the sound of what they all agreed was the catalytic converter rattling. I made a u-turn in the middle of the street, and as I started onto the sidewalk, having made a left turn, I could hear the grinding noise, and I thought maybe it was the transmission, and I wouldn't make it. But sure enough, I got the van into the service bay, and the repairman said in Spanish that he needed a key which I gave him and that he wouldn't be able to do anything with it till Monday; the problem he identified was the catalytic converter. I told him there was another noise not just the rattle, a loud grinding noise coming from the rear as well. I mangled the Spanish so badly he had no idea what I was saying, so another worker translated. One day, I'm really going to have to learn to speak this tongue properly!

The repairman said that they'd find out on Monday what was wrong. I said OK, but that I needed my bags from the van. He said that the building was alarmed so what was inside would be safe. I was carrying a load of mostly books to our place in NM. I really wasn't worried about the stuff.

I thanked him and told the woman that I would be out of town next week, but she had my contact information and could reach me at that phone number no matter where I was. She thanked me and said they would call on Monday as soon as they knew what was wrong and I could decide what to do then.

I thanked her and the rest of the staff and set out to meet my ride -- who was on her way and would probably arrive in about half an hour/45 minutes by my estimation. I passed by the woman at the transit stop again. She'd moved to a bench closer to the street, probably so she could see what was going on better. She asked me if I thought they could get the van going again. I said I didn't know, they couldn't do anything until Monday. She asked me where I was from. I said I'd come from Sacramento.

She said, "Oh, I thought you were from out of state, don't you have New Mexico license plates?" Well, there's only one, but yes, it is from New Mexico. I told her NM was my other home and I was headed that way when the van broke down. Oh, she was so sorry. She said she hoped they could get it going again, so I could continue on my way, and I said, "Yes, I hope so, too. We'll find out day after tomorrow." She said, "Oh, I hope it is good news!" and she gave me such a big smile. I thanked her and continued walking. The boy was gone, whether he got on a bus or not, I don't know. The girls were gone from the intersection, too. But traffic was even heavier than before.

I next encountered an older couple trying to negotiate the freeway overpass on foot, with the wind blowing strong in their faces. I was grateful that the wind was more or less at my back (it was really more from the side but gusts were in all directions). The woman was carrying what looked like a sack of groceries. The man was trying to keep his hat on his head. The sidewalk was narrow, the wind was high. I was carrying bags, too. We managed to do a little dance to get by one another, and the man laughed at our mutual predicament.

Yes. Indeed. I thought maybe their car had broken down too. And we made do.

I managed to get to the convenient McDonald's at the foot of the overpass and set myself up in a corner with a soft drink to wait. I recalled that McDs often have WiFi, and sure enough, this one did, so I decided to check alternative travel ideas, including going back and renting a car for the trip to NM while the van was being repaired. And then I thought I was just completely crazy for thinking that way. The trip would have to be postponed. That's all there was to it. Shortly my ride called and said she had arrived. I told her where I was, and we met. She drove us back north and we discussed various alternatives, the thought being that if the van was repaired by next weekend, I would plan to come back to Atwater, pick up the van and continue to NM. She'd drive me back to pick up the van.

As we were discussing this, I thought how incredibly lucky I really was and how even a setback like this is mild compared to what so many Americans are going through. Perspective.

So we get back to Sacramento, the cat is rolling around beguilingly ("I knew you'd be back," she seems to be saying), we have a lovely dinner, laugh and chat, and all of a sudden I hear what sounds like a parade outside. No, it's a modern music (think Jonathan Richman) band warming up in a neighbor's back yard, and after a while they start to play, and they are really very good. Now years ago, when we first moved to this neighborhood, there was a band that rehearsed at a house nearby that was not very good. I never knew which house they were rehearsing at, but it may have been the house where this band is playing. (They're playing as I type.)

And I think how very nice this impromptu concert is. Isn't that something. What a surprise, and as it happens, a treat.

Setbacks and surprising joy.

A hundred miles each direction, a dozen or so interesting people, each with their own passions and situations, a day in the life...




Friday, June 8, 2012

One Thing After Another





Several FOIA requests regarding the FBI and DHS and others vs Occupy have produced intriguing results. 

Not surprisingly, what they show is that the Federal Government has been actively coordinating a mutual response to the Occupy efforts which at times has included violent assaults by militarized police on encampments, nonviolent protests and demonstrations.

It's not surprising because it was obvious as it was going on last October and November. The strategy was clear enough: break up and destroy the encampments, disperse their denizens, prevent them from coming back. Use infiltration and monitoring online communications for intelligence, conduct mass arrests, confiscate and destroy campers' property, present the appearance of overwhelming force. Meet any resistance with "measured" brutality.

Later, the strategy changed somewhat to include stings and set ups such as have been used against Muslims and others for many years, and the widespread replacement of mass arrests with "snatch-and-grab" take-downs and kidnappings of supposed leaders/troublemakers of protests and demonstrations. At the NATO conference in Chicago, authorities utilized the tactic of night raids and arrests of people (apparently targeted by infiltrators) who might commit crimes.

Anyone who was paying attention could suss out the official strategy toward the suppression of Occupy rather easily. That it was a coordinated strategy between dozens of local police forces was also obvious. What wasn't necessarily clear prior to the release of some of the documentation recently acquired was how it was all being coordinated through DHS and the FBI. Those aspects are still not entirely clear, and they probably won't be for some time to come. The outline, however, is straightforward.

Interestingly, some of those who have looked at these documents and considered their implications have come to the conclusion that what has been released is in the nature of a government leak -- in other words, that the authorities want this information to be known throughout the Occupy community so as to thwart any idea that somehow The People are winning -- or that they can win against an implacable and coordinated militarized force of police and a solid phalanx of dedicated civic bodies.

I'd say that's a little bit of a leap, but it's not too far fetched.

So far, it seems, the strategies of suppression that have been employed have worked pretty well.

And propaganda, of course, is a major part of any suppression strategy. Propaganda is the key.

"Leaked" documents detailing a portion of the coordination through DHS is an effective form of propaganda.

One of the more startling things I've noticed with regard to Occupy from my groundling perspective is just how obvious the strategies employed to suppress the movement have been and how successful they have been in achieving their objectives.

I saw this video yesterday regarding Chicago, and I think it is worth paying attention to, for the speaker, Jerry Boyle (the man in the suit) explains at length and in detail just what kind of strategies are being employed against protests and demonstrations and what their purpose is -- as well as some of the history behind them. 



Video streaming by Ustream

Boyle points out that the authorities are engaging in warfare against dissenters. Their objectives are clear:

 Those objectives include making sure that "good people" are so frightened by the potential for violence -- whether by the police or "black bloc" doesn't really matter -- that they will stay away from support or participation in Occupy. In the background all the time is the fear of the "terrorist" label -- which is being applied more and more openly by civic authorities against Occupy and the other anti-globalist protests, with a particular emphasis now on the upcoming political conventions in Charlotte and Tampa.


Now that the encampments are almost all destroyed, the objectives of the authorities include making sure that they don't come back primarily through show of force and intimidation tactics which seem to have been worked out and fine tuned in Oakland and New York City.

Boyle's advice is to remain flexible and unpredictable among other things. Yes, well...

Meanwhile, the indifference and unresponsiveness of government and institutions to the plight of the People is expected to continue without remorse or let up indefinitely. The only things the Ruling Class seems interested in -- besides gambling, war and resource extraction and control -- is taking away what little remains of peoples well being and economic security so as to backstop any potential losses at the top of the finance pyramid.


We're in for one thing after another for the duration.